Lower Student COVID Rate in Mask Optional Schools, Billings Mask Lawsuit, State Data Shows

Yellowstone County Schools COVID Case Rate Per 10k Students, Mask Optional vs Required, DPHHS, MontanaStatistics.com.

Like Missoula County Tyranny?
Get it delivered to your inbox.

UPDATED (1/6/2022): Post updated to include letter from Billings teachers union president Douglas Robison discouraging educators from contributing statements to the lawsuit regarding the negative effects of masks on students.

Parents in Billings and the non-profit Stand Up Montana filed their 200-page mask lawsuit against Billings Public Schools and Elysian Schools at the end of December. A hearing date for a preliminary injunction against forced-masking has been set for January 28th, at 9:00am with Judge Jessica Fehr. The injunction would halt the forced masking of children in these public school districts.

In the brief, parents provide data on mask efficacy and affidavits from three Billing area school teachers who testify to the harm that masks cause students. There are also affidavits from a Billings-area infectious diseases physician and a biostatistician discussing mask efficacy and statistically low COVID risk for children.

One teacher, Tanya Watt, a 2nd grade teacher at Billings Public Schools, shared that she had not spoken out against the district mask policies for fear of “retribution or backlash.”

“I have been a teacher for 23 years, 16 of those in title schools in SD2,” Watt wrote. “I love my job, my students and my school. But, I also feel like I need to stand up for my students, parents and myself in this situation. I have been debating sending this email for a long time, but haven’t for fear of retribution or backlash. I can’t continue to stand by any longer.”

In her affidavit, a letter addressed to school board members and Billing Public Schools Superintendent Greg Upham, Watt explained that they were dividing the community over the forced masking policy. She also said the policy was creating a hostile work environment and that the school was at risk of losing staff.

“This mask mandate is dividing our community and creating hostile work environments at our schools,” she wrote. “You have created an environment of anger, fear, anxiety and disgruntled employees. I am so thankful for the school I work at that we have a strong “family”, but I know of several schools where this is not the case. Please take this into consideration before you lose valuable employees who have worked tirelessly throughout this pandemic to do what is best, and are just worn out.”

Watts noted that students are suffering from head aches, skin rashes, and nose bleeds while being forced to wear a mask all day. She also mentioned that the Yellowstone County Health Officer was not comparing cases between schools who forced masking and schools that made it optional. She said that the schools where masking is optional, positive COVID cases are actually lower.

“These young kids are being forced to wear a mask all day, endure headaches, skin rashes, nose bleeds,” Watts wrote. “This is quite a burden to put on these children! They are taking the brunt of this pandemic and it is, quite honestly, just wrong! I have watched several of your board meetings with all of the numbers and data shown by [Yellowstone County Health Officer] Mr. [John] Felton. However, not once, has it been shown that these schools with mandated mask policies are doing any better than schools with an optional policy.”

In the suit, parents provided COVID case data collected from the Montana Department of Public Health and Human Services (DPHHS). State data shows that in Yellowstone County mask optional schools have lower case rates than schools that force masks. The data tracks cases at 66 schools in Yellowstone County over a three month period. Schools that forced masking had a COVID positivity rate of 4.25% while mask-optional schools had a 3.42% positivity rate.

DPHHS data indicates that forced masking at schools has no effect on reducing the spread of COVID-19.

Yellowstone County Schools COVID Case Rate, Mask Optional vs Required, DPHHS, MontanaStatistics.com.

One parent, Luke Hudson, who is also named as a plaintiff in the lawsuit, has been collecting and graphing state COVID case data for other parents and for the lawsuit.

Hudson setup a website called MontanaStatistics.com where he uses DPHHS data to provide visualizations not available in the state’s online COVID tracker. He has collected state data to graph school COVID case rates in Yellowstone County, including between schools with different masking policies, in addition to graphs of hospital capacity in the Billings area and statewide.

A preliminary injunction requesting a halt to forced masking filed against Missoula County Schools on behalf of Missoula parents was rejected by Judge Jason Marks in October of 2021. Missoula schools attorney Elizabeth Kaleva argued that emergency injunctions are granted to preserve the status quo and that since parents in Missoula County did not legally challenge the school mask policy in 2020, masking became the uncontested status quo moving forward. Judge Marks agreed.

Hudson said that he is optimistic about the hearing on the 28th. “I am eternally optimistic about our case,” Hudson said. “We have a few things now that Missoula and Bozeman didn’t have. We have heard from judges in Missoula and Bozeman so we have the benefit of hearing their defense of masks.”

Hudson shared that the teacher affidavits and local data on masks will help bolster the Yellowstone County lawsuit. “We have built our case around the fact that masks are an educational harm to schools,” Hudson said.

“We have several teacher affidavits testifying of the harms of masks. We have an affidavit from an infectious disease doctor testifying that masks are not effective in schools. We have this data showing masks are not the least restrictive means of mitigation since other schools are open in person with optional masking. We have been fighting the district in Billings since last February so they can’t claim status quo against us.”

After publishing this story, Billings teachers union President Douglas Robison wrote to 1,100 educator members on January 6th, warning them not to share statements regarding the negative impacts of masking on students. 

“I am writing to discourage you from speaking out against your employer in this capacity. While they are promising anonymity, I can’t confirm that that will happen,” Robison wrote.  “Ultimately it is your decision to participate, but in my professional opinion and under the advice of others I would discourage you from participating.”

Letter from Billings teachers union President Douglas Robison discouraging teachers from speaking up on negative effects of masking students. January 6th, 2021.

Read the lawsuit here.


Roy McKenzie

Roy McKenzie has lived in Missoula since 2017 and runs his own software development company. Roy is the Editor of Missoula County Tyranny. Get in touch with him on Telegram.


Trending posts from the blog and the Firehose

MacKenzie: Healthcare Denied in Flathead—And Nationwide

Kalispell man refused medical care and kidney transplant for not submitting to testing and vaccination. Logan Health refused lab tests without COVID test.

WATCH: “We have to break through our private idea that kids belong to their parents.”

Seriously warped!

WATCH: Ontario MPP Questions Health Minister on Jump in Stillborns in Vaccinated Waterloo Women

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cx7ICPIOnck&t=5s Ontario MPP Rick Nicholls asked Deputy Premier and Minister of Health Christine Elliot during a Question Period if vaccines were safe for pregnant mothers due to a startling increase in stillbi...

Helena Public Schools: Masks Required, Cloth Masks Are Not “Adequate” for Omicron

"Please do not use single-layer cloth masks, which are not considered adequate to prevent Omicron per CDC and Lewis and Clark Public Health recommendations.”

Guess who just confirmed to be at our Ad Hoc Committee Election Hearing?

Guess who just confirmed to be at our Ad Hoc Committee Hearing! https://rumble.com/embed/vid807/?pub=gynzf

30 of 56 Montana Counties Including Missoula Granted Zuckerberg Money for Elections, Legislature Investigating

Last October, over 2,500 election offices across the country received undisclosed sums of money from the Mark Zuckerberg-funded Center for Tech & Civic Life (CTCL). The organization was funded by Zuckerberg and his wife, Priscilla Chan, to the tu...

Montana Democrats Share Photo of “Freezer Morgue” That’s Actually A Mobile MRI Unit, Hospital Says

Former Lt. Governor Mike Cooney, Senator Ellie Boldman, and Helena Commissioner Emily Dean spread misinformation about a mobile MRI trailer being a portable COVID "freezer morgue"

Looking at German Myocarditis & Pericarditis cases (blue), we can clearly…

Looking at German Myocarditis & Pericarditis cases (blue), we can clearly see: > No correlation between COVID-19 cases. (Red) > Clear correlation towards vaccination. (Green) @USMortality

Dr. Paul Marik | New Hampshire Ivermectin Bill

Dr. Paul Marik | New Hampshire Ivermectin Bill Heather Mullins reports on New Hampshire's Ivermectin bill and Dr. Paul Merik's testimony that Ivermectin is safer than Tylenol. "It is very safe, it is very cheap, and it is highly effective against S...

Roxy Theater Cancels Showing of Documentary Critical of Mayor Engen’s Administration

The Roxy Theater in Missoula cancelled a showing of a forthcoming documentary critical of Mayor John Engen's 14-year administration titled Engen's Missoula citing "overbooking." Three days after signing a contract with the producer at the beginni...

Mass Formation Psychosis has been in effect for at least a…

Mass Formation Psychosis has been in effect for at least a century. It’s their mechanism for herding us like cattle. The only difference at present is that it’s plainly fucking obvious and far more people are awake to this programming. — JuliansRum

Community Hospital To Fire Unvaccinated Workers Despite Losing 26% of Beds Since September

Many nurses and healthcare workers have been seeing the writing on the wall for months now. Hospitals across the United States have been sending notices to their workers, pressuring them to get vaccinated. On Veteran's Day, Missoula's Community Medic...

The narrative is collapsing. Listen to someone who originally fell for…

The narrative is collapsing. Listen to someone who originally fell for it hook and line and sinker: "We were told: You get the vaccine and you get back to normal. And we haven't gotten back to normal." She then admits that cloth masks don't work, pa...

The Cult of Masked Schoolchildren

“When the history books are written, we will not look wise or kind for insisting that kids and toddlers wear masks for hours on end, year after year, without ever testing this policy with controlled trials. We will look ignorant, cruel, fearful, and...

Alberton Principal Threatens To Call Police on Students Who Protest Masks Friday

A national movement of parents, students, teachers, and staff called Mom's For Liberty has set tomorrow, September 10th, as a nationwide school walkout event protesting mask mandates. The walkout is set to start at 10 AM. Parents of Alberton Schoo...

Amber Sherrill and Mike Nugent

Missoula City Council Candidate “Honored” to Receive Endorsement from Exiting Councilor Who Mandated Masks

Ward 4 candidate Mike Nugent announced on his Facebook page that he was "honored" to have the endorsement of incumbent Ward 4 councilwoman, Amber Sherrill. Sherrill will not seek re-election this year and bears partial responsibility for mask mandate...

WATCH: Missoula Schools Trustee Declines Mask, Chair Suspends Meeting for “Spreading Germs”

On Tuesday night, the regular meeting of the Missoula County Public Schools (MCPS) Board of Trustees was suspended by board chair Diane Lorenzen after trustee Mike Gehl declined to wear a mask. An agenda item that was set for discussion was Montana H...

Missoulian Publisher Jim Strauss and Editor Jim Van Nostrand Pen Editorial School Board’s Gehl a “Poor Example”

Missoulian Publisher Jim Strauss and Executive Editor Jim Van Nostrand penned an editorial about Missoula School Board member Mike Gehl who declined to wear a mask at a school board meeting. The editorial board headline said Gehl was a “poor example...

“When that penny starts to drop, the general public are going to be revolted”

Dr. Roger Hodkinson does not mince words: "When that penny starts to drop, the general public are going to be revolted." Watch and share.

“End the Mandates” Missoula Freedom Rally Set for January 23rd

The Western Montana Liberty Coalition and Missoula-based Face of Freedom are inviting freedom loving Missoulians to join them for an "End the Mandates" rally to coincide with the World Wide Rally for Freedom, Sunday, January 23rd. "The people who...

Regarding Masks Mandates, Montana Governor and State Superintendent Urge School Boards, Administrators to Listen to Parents and Science

"As we have heard from hundreds of parents across Montana, it is critical our kids get back into the classroom in as normal a setting."

Drop #7671

Telegram post from CodeMonkeyZ [Ron Watkins]:

Biden: “ Anyone responsible for that many deaths should not be…

Biden: “ Anyone responsible for that many deaths should not be President of the United States” Really? That’s the standard? Q: GUESS WHO is responsible for more deaths? A: Mr. Joe “I will end this” Biden. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ce9_pV...

Guest on CNN: “We built five years of coverage on Trump…

Guest on CNN: "We built five years of coverage on Trump on Russia, Covid and democracy. The President at his press conference invites Russia to invade the Ukraine, we got more deaths under Biden than Trump, and now have the President and Vice Preside...

Dr Robert Malone-there’s gonna have to be a reckoning- People still…

Dr Robert Malone-there’s gonna have to be a reckoning- People still look to America for leader ship the shiny city on the hill the Camelot- We can become that again

VIDEO: President Donald Trump Mentions 6% Discrepancy Found in Missoula County Ballots During Save America Rally in Ohio Saturday

"In Montana over 6% of a certain county's mail-in ballots are missing evidence to prove if they were legitimate or not. They're missing all of this evidence. And think of it, Montana."

New from POTUS45 Have a blessed Thanksgiving. Trust the plan. —…

New from POTUS45 Have a blessed Thanksgiving. Trust the plan. — Praying Medic

Mateer: “School Board Trustee Mike Gehl Is Exposing The Cheap Theatrics And Empty Posturing Of MCPS And Its Missoulian Media Enablers”

“Mike Gehl’s move, and the hilarious reaction to it, is just what we need to inspire more sane people to come forward and run for open board positions.” https://zoomchron.com/2022/01/16/school-board-trustee-mike-gehl-is-exposing-the-cheap-theatri...

Take the red pill.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Do you trust the Missoulian media outlet?
Will you vaccinate your child?
Do you trust the Missoula City-County Health Department?


Neil Oliver’s latest covid monologue, this guy has a second to none way with words 🙏🏻

In the middle of a supply chain crisis, Biden is banning unvacinated Mexican and Canadian truckers from delivering goods to American stores.

Starting today.


This should read – Sinema unable to be blackmailed or bought off. Fellow colleagues sell her out because they are.


Liberty Loving Legislators all over the country are hosting these Election Integrity Ad Hoc Hearings to take comment from citizens and gather information and evidence to identify and address the vulnerabilities in our election systems.